You are stopped at a light. A jolt from behind snaps your head forward. By dinner, a pink haze creeps across your vision—like a bubble that will not pop—yet the ER says you’re stable and sends you home. Days later you learn that “a formula,” not your lived reality, could decide whether that new blind spot is “worth” anything.
That is close to what happened in Nanaimo, British Columbia. A rear-end crash in November 2021 left a B.C., artist with a posterior vitreous detachment (PVD), and a persistent pink dot in his field of view. Under B.C.’s “enhanced care” (no-fault) model, he could not sue the at-fault driver. ICBC calculated a zero permanent-impairment rating using its vision formula, and the Civil Resolution Tribunal agreed he had a permanent, crash-caused injury—but still awarded $0 under the regulation. ICBC publicly acknowledged the outcome “may seem unorthodox” and said it will look at improvements. (Global News)
How eye injuries happen in otherwise “minor” collisions
Sudden deceleration can tug on the gel inside the eye (the vitreous). In a PVD, that gel pulls away from the retina. For some people it passes with only “floaters;” for others it leaves a stubborn haze, or a fixed blob that covers what you need to see—fine print, lane markings, a child stepping off a curb. That symptom does not always show up on a quick eye chart.
Airbag inflation, frontal head impact, or even whiplash forces can trigger or worsen vitreoretinal traction. Glass chips, chemical irritation from airbag propellant, or a laceration to the eyelid/eye can add to the damage. Importantly, flashes of light, a “curtain” over part of your vision, or a surge of floaters can signal a retinal tear or detachment—conditions where hours matter.
The lesson: a crash that looks repair-shop small can be medically big if it involves your eyes.
The fallout is more than “annoying floaters”
Vision changes derail routines you take for granted. Graphic and design work becomes slow and error-prone. Night driving feels risky. Headaches and eye strain cut into sleep. Income suffers when you cannot focus long enough to meet deadlines. Family life tightens around appointments and compensating for lost capacity. Administratively, you are asked to prove the unprovable: a fixed pink blob that is real to you, but hard to quantify in a clinic. In the B.C. case, the tribunal accepted the injury and permanence, yet the “formula”—based on distance acuity, visual field degrees lost, and diplopia—produced a zero rating, which multiplied by a statutory figure of $167,465 still equalled $0. (Global News)
Prevention that actually helps:
You can’t eliminate all risk, but you can cut it:
- Reduce crash forces. Leave real following distance, ease into yellow lights, and cap speed in rain or on gravel. Less force means less tug on the vitreous and fewer glass/airbag injuries if things go sideways;
- Set up your seat for safety. Sit at least 25 cm (10 inches) from the steering wheel. Aim the wheel toward your chest, not your face. Adjust the head restraint high and close to the back of your head;
- Control the cabin. Secure laptops, water bottles, and tools so they don’t become eye-level projectiles in a sudden stop. Keep the windshield chip-free and wipers fresh, so you’re not squinting at glare; and
- Protective eyewear when appropriate. If you wear prescription glasses, use shatter-resistant lenses; for certain work-vehicle tasks, keep safety glasses on until you are fully off the site.
What to do right after a crash if your vision is “off”
Timing and documentation make or break, eye-injury claims:
- Seek medical care immediately—and ask for an eye exam referral. Tell providers about any flashes, new floaters, pink haze, or a “curtain” in your vision. Push for an urgent ophthalmology assessment; some retinal problems are treatable if caught early;
- Write down what you see. Start a dated log: when the blob appears, size, colour, which tasks it blocks (reading street signs, spreadsheet cells), and how long relief lasts after breaks;
- Preserve physical evidence. Keep damaged glasses, contact lens packets, and any photos of your eyes or facial bruising. Photograph the interior, airbags, and any glass on seats;
- Limit statements to insurers. Stick to facts. Don’t downplay symptoms with “I’m fine.” Early, casual comments often reappear months later in claim decisions;
- Collect witnesses and images. Save dashcam clips. Get names and numbers of bystanders who heard you describe vision changes at the scene; and
- Consult experienced counsel early. An early legal consult helps you avoid pitfalls, coordinate independent medical opinions, and preserve the right evidence. (Waiting until a denial hits your inbox is emotionally understandable, but strategically costly.)
Legal insight: Alberta is not B.C.—but evidence still rules
The Nanaimo decision arose under B.C.’s no-fault model. Alberta uses a fault-based system where, outside of certain capped “minor injuries,” you typically pursue damages from the at-fault driver and their insurer. The takeaway, regardless of province: link your symptoms to the crash with timely, specialist-level documentation. Insurers and tribunals rely on measurable criteria. If your impairment doesn’t fit a chart (as in B.C.’s eye-efficiency formula), the more contemporaneous and detailed your medical record is, the better your position. In the Global News case, even with two levels acknowledging permanence, compensation was still zero under the regulation’s math—a stark reminder to build your file from day one. (Global News)
If your claim raises complex medical questions—PVD vs. glaucoma, for example—don’t be shy about requesting a referral to an ophthalmologist with trauma experience, or a second opinion. Independent exams and functional assessments can capture how a “small” visual defect wrecks real-world tasks.
Why call a lawyer now, not later
Eye injuries are invisible until they are not—usually when work quality dips or driving confidence crashes. A seasoned injury lawyer will: coordinate specialist opinions, frame your day-to-day limitations in legal terms, identify future care costs (vision therapy, assistive tech), and protect you from statements that devalue your claim. Pipella Law has over 75 years of combined experience representing crash victims in Calgary on a contingency basis—no fees until you win—so you can focus on medical care while we shoulder the administrative and legal load.
If you or someone you love has been injured in a motor vehicle accident, Pipella Law is here to help. Contact us today for a free consultation at (403)265-8733 or log onto www.pipellalaw.com – You don’t pay unless we win.
Kindly lobby your MLA and spread the word to help put a stop to NO FAULT in Alberta. Log onto https://fairab.ca/; and https://www.notonofault.com/ for more info on the effects on auto insurance changes in BC and how they will impact you, your family and all Albertans.
https://chng.it/M96xLCQdMW Petition against No-Fault Auto Insurance
If you or a loved one have been involved in an accident, you know how devastating the consequences can be. That's why having an experienced personal injury lawyer on your side is crucial to help you navigate the legal system and obtain the compensation you need to cover your medical bills, lost wages, and long-term care in Alberta.
At Pipella Law, we understand the challenges you are facing, and we are here to help. Our team of dedicated car accident lawyers in Calgary will conduct a complete investigation of your case and work with leading consultants to build a strong case on your behalf.